Meta Pulls Muse Image AI After Hollywood Privacy Backlash
Meta has pulled its Muse Image AI feature from Instagram and the Meta AI app just three days after launch, citing user privacy concerns.
The Upshurt
The tool, developed by Meta Superintelligence Labs, allowed anyone to generate images based on public Instagram account photos without explicit consent. This sparked a strong reaction from Hollywood professionals, including talent agencies and actors like Hannah Einbinder.
"Our intent was to provide a useful creative tool… but we’ve heard the feedback that this feature missed the mark, so it’s no longer available." stated Meta in a Friday announcement.
What Muse Image Did
The AI feature, integrated into Meta’s chatbot on Instagram and WhatsApp, let users generate images based on public Instagram profiles. While private accounts and users under 18 were excluded by default, all other users had to opt-out to prevent their photos from being used.
This design sparked comparisons to Meta’s historical treatment of user data, often relying on an "opt-out" rather than "opt-in" model.
Hollywood’s Response
The backlash was swift:
-
SAG-AFTRA, representing over 160,000 film and television workers, urged members to opt out. They stated that anything less than a clear and conspicuous opt-in for image use is unacceptable.
-
Talent agency CAA echoed this sentiment, emphasizing the importance of documented consent before using anyone’s name, likeness, or creative work in AI models.
-
Hannah Einbinder, an Emmy-winning actress, also spoke out against the feature on Instagram, prompting her followers to disable it.
Met with criticism, Mark Zuckerberg initially defended the tool’s safety measures but Meta subsequently reversed course within 24 hours.
This event highlights a recurring pattern for Meta: launching AI features that prioritize open access to user data, then backing down when public outcry ensues.